Estimated Reading Time: 6 minutes
Executive Director
My Dad took pride in his collection of well-made, always organized shop tools. He loved showing me the cross pein pin hammer that was part of the set he purchased as a young aircraft mechanic apprentice. He’d explain that his original toolset lasted because the tools were well made. After dropping a teeny screw into a crevice on a friend’s Norton Atlas, he sent me to his workshop—which family and friends always refer to as The Batcave—to find the perfect tool for the job: a wire with a magnet on the end. The tool did the work our fat fingers could not.
In See Sooner, Act Faster: How Vigilant Leaders Thrive in an Era of Digital Turbulence, authors George S. Day and Paul J. H. Schoemaker remind us that choosing the right tool for the task at hand is fundamental to vigilance. They write, “In some cases, the right tool will be a telescope to look over the broad horizon; at other times, a microscope is better to examine a small part of the terrain in great detail.”
In the NRMC’s experience, risk oversight teams often clamor for a “deep dive” presentation on worrisome risks. After nodding politely during an overview of the high-level perspective required for sound risk oversight, they insist on looking through the lens of a microscope to validate their inclination that management is indeed managing risks. Day and Schoemaker caution that a close-up view is potentially dangerous because “the data mostly comes from familiar sources, can be overwhelming in volume, and is largely interpreted to reinforce rather than challenge prevailing beliefs.”
The alternative to data diving is “active scanning,” emphasizing curiosity about uncertainties “driven by creative hypotheses that shed new light on the preliminary evidence collected thus far.” They liken such scanning to the scientific method and encourage scanners to begin with multiple hypotheses and continue with keen observation and further speculation. The end game of the process is “deeper insights” that inspire action.
Nonprofit teams heading into strategic planning sessions often carry a familiar item of baggage: the SWOT analysis. Day and Schoemaker caution their readers that the SWOT analysis might not be the right tool after all. Essentially, a SWOT analysis might end up being a hamster wheel – a device that feels productive but doesn’t actually take you anywhere and only takes into account a stationary moment in time, not the dynamic nature of risk.
A typical SWOT can lead teams off course by narrowing and anchoring conversations about strategy. Day and Schoemaker write that the SWOT analysis “focuses on understanding current strengths and weaknesses as well as opportunities and threats. . . the very use of such labels as threat or opportunity…implicitly assumes the status quo as the relevant reference point. This may indeed be a valid benchmark, but an outside-in view would favor more neutral labels such as ‘issues or developments that deserve attention. This avoids prejudging these factors as either good or bad a priori and getting trapped in a self-fulfilling prophecy about threats specifically.’”
Risk Leaders must select and use the right tool for the job at hand. Sometimes, deciding what method to choose can be as daunting as designing a feasible risk action plan that will earn cheers, not jeers. While it isn’t always easy to select the ‘right tool’ or the approach that is an ideal fit for your culture and circumstances, below are a few rules of thumb that might be useful.
To escape the hamster wheel or the feeling of feeling stuck, invite your audit or risk oversight committee or full board to join you in scanning the complex, dynamic risk landscape, including the distant horizon. Lift up and discuss landscape features that could be relevant to the risks you might face or be inspired to embrace.
Skilled oversight teams are unafraid to jump into the conversation by sharing their unique lenses and vantage points. Disparate and sometimes distant elements of that landscape are revealed and reflected upon. Try these question prompts to get a creative conversation started:
At my Dad’s funeral, we distributed a small card with his favorite expressions. We knew that our “Tony-isms” would bring a smile to the faces of the standing-room-only crowd of friends, neighbors, and vintage motorcycle enthusiasts/gearheads. One of those expressions, “If I don’t have it, you don’t need it,” was a reminder of Dad’s extraordinary tool collection and his never-ending eagerness to share what he had and knew. Dad was an always determined and optimistic problem-solver who loved sharing his expertise, learning new things, and demonstrating how the right tool for the job could make a difference.
As you reflect on your risk function, your evolving ERM program, or your skillset as a risk leader, I encourage you to build a set of tools that will serve your nonprofit’s mission well. Discard poorly constructed approaches that lead nowhere—your hamster wheels. Select tools and strategies that deepen your understanding of the risks you face and inspire creative thinking about the risk-taking your mission warrants. Don’t hesitate before creating or adapting a tool that will meet your needs right now. Need help finding—or creating—the right tool for the risk task at hand? Reach out and let us help you. You’re welcome to everything we have.
Melanie Lockwood Herman is Executive Director of the Nonprofit Risk Management Center. She welcomes your questions and stories about developing the right tools for any risk job in a nonprofit. Reach out to share your stories or questions to Melanie@nonprofitrisk.org or 703-777-3504.
“First let me congratulate you on a conference well done. I had a great time at the Nonprofit Employee Benefits Conference and walked away with some valuable tools and questions that we’ll need to be addressing in both the short and long term. Thanks to you and your staff for all you do to provide us with quality resources in support of our missions.”
“BBYO’s engagement of NRMC to conduct a risk assessment was one of the most valuable processes undertaken over the past five years. Numerous programmatic and procedural changes were recommended and have since been implemented. Additionally, dozens (literally) of insurance coverage gaps were identified that would never have been without the work of NRMC. This assessment led to a broker bidding process that resulted in BBYO’s selection of a new broker that we have been extremely satisfied with. I unconditionally recommend the Center for their consultative services.
“Melanie Herman has provided expert, insightful, timely and well resourced information to our Executive Team and Board of Directors. Our corporation recently experienced massive growth through merger and the Board has been working to better integrate their expanded set of roles and responsibilities. Melanie presented at our Annual Board of Director’s Retreat and captured the interest of our Board members. As a result of her excellent presentation the Board has engaged in focused review which is having immediate effects on governance.”
“The Nonprofit Risk Management Center has been an outstanding partner for us. They are attentive to our needs, and work hard to successfully meet our requests for information. Being an Affiliate member gave us access to so many time- and money-saving resources that it easily paid for itself! Nonprofit Risk Management Center is truly a valued partner of The Community Foundation of Elkhart County and we are continuously able to optimize staff time with the support given by their team.”
“The board and staff of the Prince George’s Child Resource Center are extremely pleased with the results of the risk assessment conducted by the Nonprofit Risk Management Center. A thorough scan revealed that while we are a well run organization, we had risks that we never imagined. We are grateful to know that we have now minimized our organizational risks and we recommend the Center to other nonprofits.”
Great American Insurance Group’s Specialty Human Services is committed to protecting those who improve your communities. The NRMC team has committed to delivering dynamic risk management solutions tailored to nonprofit organizations. These organizations have many and varied risk issues, hence the need for specialized coverage and expert knowledge for their protection. We’ve had Melanie speak on several occasions to employees and our agents. She is always on point and delivers such great value. Thank you for the terrific partnership and allowing our nonprofits to focus on their mission!